Conflict

CONFLICT Sunset 18773c

Grace, be in peace from God our Father and from the Lord Jesus Christ His Son. Amen.

Conflict is a part of relationships and life in community

In the introduction to this Sunday, which comes from the worship planner that we use each week, it reads,
conflict is a part of relationships and life in community. You can read it right there on page two.
Conflict is a part of life for families, workplaces, and yes, in the church,
we’ve been told, don’t rock the boat, let it go or play nice.

Avoid Conflict?

We have been encouraged to avoid conflict.
Avoiding conflict doesn’t make hurt feelings and frustrations go away.
In Matthew chapter 18, Jesus gives us a way to deal with conflict in community, which 
sometimes is misused and misunderstood, leading to even more pain and anger within the community.
So I want to look at this a little more closely this morning and pay attention to a few details.

If…

First, if you look at verse 15, it reads, if your brother or sister sins against you, sins against you.
Matthew 18 is not something that we are encouraged to use in reproaching someone who we think is sinning.
This is a passage about restoring and maintaining relationships. It is about building and rebuilding trust.

P.B. & J

So let’s say two friends are walking together, P.B. and J. And J makes a joke.
It wasn’t meant to be hurtful, but PB is offended. Matthew says that PB is to go to
J by himself and say, you may not have meant it this way, but that joke bothered me.
And if Jay apologizes, then P being J is great and there’s no further need to drag it out.
However, if Jay gets defensive or makes fun of PB because he can’t take a joke, t
hen PB should go and find a couple friends and then go back to Jay.
And here’s another place where this gets misunderstood and misused.
You see, the witnesses that PB brings along to talk to J are not there to gang up on J
and tell Jay that she is mean and an immature person who needs to grow up again.

The Witnesses to the conflict

Witnesses are not there to gang up on Jay.
The role of the witnesses in Matthew 18 is to listen to both sides,to listen impartially and if needed,
help J hear what PB is saying and to help PB here what Jay is saying.
So what I hear Jay saying is that she didn’t mean to be a jerk, but that joke was her way of saying she was uncomfortable.
Hey Jay, what I hear PB say is that maybe you could have said the same thing a little nicer rather than making a joke about it.
Sometimes when we are hurt or we’re defensive, we cannot always hear what the other person is trying to say.

Help Listening

And a third party may be able to help us listen to each other.
That’s what Jesus is advocating for in Matthew 18.
This is the way that Jesus gives us as his followers to begin resolving our differences.

Why don’t we?

However, we rarely do this. We rarely go to the person who has hurt our feelings or made us angry.
Why? Because we don’t want to be called oversensitive or because we think it’s more trouble
than it’s worth and so we push it down or we just walk away.
Or maybe we tell another person that we’re angry and hurt,
sometimes hoping that the third person will go to the offender and confront them.
PB is angry with him. Check. You need to fix it.

Vulnerability

We don’t go directly to the person who has hurt us because to admit that we are feeling angry
or that we are hurt is to expose ourselves. It is to be vulnerable to another person and vulnerability does not feel safe.
Dealing with conflict also requires us to be self reflective and honest about our own feelings.
And we are not always able to listen and be self reflective.

Jesus understands us

Jesus understands this because Jesus understands us. Jesus knows how we think and behave.
Jesus knows that most people avoid conflict and so he gives us this incredible gift in Matthew 18.
By the way, if you look up in our Constitution, it’s included in every congregational constitution in the ELCA. 
This is the prescribed manner for dealing with conflicts in church.

Conflict resolved

Years ago, a woman shared a story with me after reading this week’s Gospel.
She went to see an old friend whom she had not spoken to in years.
She’d been hurt by a comment her friend made and and so she cut her off and walked away from the relationship.
This woman went and visited her friend and explained how hurt she had been when
this comment was made and her friend immediately apologized. She had not meant it the way that it was heard.
And slowly the two women were able to begin to restore the once broken record relationship.
How sad that so many years have been lost over a misunderstanding.

Will it work?

Is it always going to work out this way now? And honestly,
there are times when using Matthew 18 to resolve conflict is not safe.
There are people who may be abusive or violent and those are probably times you don’t want to use Matthew.
Jesus loves us. That’s the core of our theology. We are loved by God to death and to resurrection through Jesus.
And Jesus loves us each individually and as community. And Jesus does not want to see us hurting as individuals or as community.
Jesus does not want to see the seeds of division sown within the body of Christ.

One body!

As Paul reminds us, we are one body.For just as the body is one and has many members,
and all the members of the body, though many are one body, so it is with Christ.
Then Paul goes on to say, if one member suffers, the whole body suffers together.
And if one member of the body is on, the whole body of Christ is there.

Back to P.B. & J

If P, B and J are arguing, if they’re sniping at one another,
it can sow the seeds of dissension throughout the whole community.
People may take sides and it can hurt the fellowship they have together with the whole community.

Conflict is a part of relationships and life in community

Again, the introduction for today says, conflict is a part of relationships and life and community.
There is no way to get around that. Relationships and communities bring people together,
people who are simultaneously saint and sinners,
people who are driven consciously and unconsciously by their own wants, fears and insecurities.
And our wants, fears and insecurities can get in our way of building the loving community Jesus desires for us in the church, in the world.

God’s love for us

Brothers and sisters, God loves us unconditionally.
And because of God’s unconditional love for us, he sent Jesus to reconcile us to our Heavenly Father
and to deal with the sin that continues to try and separate us from God.
But God’s desire for reconciliation goes beyond our reconciliation with the divine.
God desires reconciliation between his children as well.
And in our Gospel reading today, we are invited to be honest and
vulnerable by going to our brothers and sisters in love,
seeking reconciliation with each other in Christ.
We belong to one another and we need each other.