The Mercy of Joseph & The Mercy of God

For devotions based on this text, click here.

For the YouTube Video, click here

Poor Old Joe

Grace to you and peace from God our Father, and from the Lord Jesus Christ his son. Amen. Poor, poor old Joseph. He is rarely remembered in the Christmas carols or the hymns. Everything is always about Mary, Mother mild.

Stable 23783c

And sometimes it seems as if. As if Joseph is merely a footnote in the Christmas story, quiet and forgotten, except in Matthew’s Gospel. In Matthew’s Gospel, Joseph steps out into the light and we are given this remarkable story which I just read to you.

Tradition tells us that Joseph was an old man with other children when he was betrothed to Mary. And when I say tradition, I mean there is no scriptural basis for this idea at all.

Protoevangelium of James

There is a place where this tradition comes from. A second century document about the verse of Jesus. This document is fanciful, humorous, a little crude, and probably preserves a grain of truth. But it was never included in the canon of Scripture.

This document is called the  Protoevangelium of James or the Infancy Gospel of James. And it gives us a very entertaining description of Mary’s birth and childhood. And she was so holy that her parents brought her to the temple. And the temple priests put her, a young girl, into the holy of holies to live. And angels brought food to her to eat.

Humorous. Fanciful. You kind of see where I’m going. When she turned 12, the elders decided, oh, we got to get her out of the Holy of Holies. And so they decided to find a righteous man for whom to marry this young girl off to.

And so they brought all of these men in, and they. They did some things. And then they said, Joseph, God has chosen you to marry Mary, to take her as your wife.

And this is from the Protoevangelium of James.

But Joseph refused, saying, I have sons and am an old man, but she is young. I won’t be a laughingstock among the people of Israel. Well, the elders cajole him, harass him, and finally he agrees.

When Mary’s 16, the angel comes to her and announcing that she will bear a child. And when her body begins to change and the child in her womb can no longer be hidden, the Protoevangelium of James imagines Mary becoming afraid of being discovered and Joseph devastated. So, again, this is from the Protoevangelium of James.

And she was in her six months. And look, Joseph came from his building and came into the house and found her pregnant.

And he struck his face and flung himself on the ground in sackcloth and wept bitterly, saying, how can I look to the Lord God? What prayer can I say about this young girl?

It’s dramatic, it’s painful. And while it is not in Scripture, it takes some thought about how Joseph would have reacted to everything that was going on in the story. Something I bet that you have wondered from time to time.

The Shame of Pregnancy outside of Marriage

It captures that fear, shock, and shame that we imagine Joseph might have felt. I mean, let’s be honest. Yes, Mary is betrothed, but she’s still considered an unwed teenager. And even 50 years ago, a young woman, a teenager, having a child outside of marriage was considered shameful.

She would be sent away, disappeared until after the child was born, and then return as if nothing had happened, saying, oh, well, I was visiting with a sick relative.

Because having a child outside of marriage was considered shameful in the past.

But 2,000 years ago, in a small Jewish village, an unmarried teenager being found pregnant was far more serious. Legally, Mary’s betrothal meant that on paper, she was married. But they had not had the ceremony, they had not had the celebration. Simply, the marriage contract had been signed, and a betrothal was legally binding and could only be severed through divorce.

When Mary was discovered to be pregnant, Joseph had the option of bringing charges against her, of accusing her of adultery, of taking her into the center of the village and accusing her. But Matthew tells us something critical. Joseph was unwilling to put her to shame.

Had Mary been found guilty, she could have been stoned to death. Joseph would have dragged could have dragged her into the center of town and publicly accused her of adultery and would have been fully within his rights under the law.

The Mercy of Jospeh

So when Matthew’s Gospel tells us that Joseph planned to divorce Mary quietly, we learn something important about his character. Joseph is merciful, Joseph is kind. Joseph is graceful and refuses to shame someone who is vulnerable even when he is the one who was wronged.

Being kind and merciful and graceful does not make someone weak or doormat. Joseph still had a deep sense of right and wrong. He does not ignore the situation, but he chooses compassion over cruelty.

Now I just read to you the rest of that story.

An angel appears to Joseph and is told that Mary was not unfaithful, but that this child is from the Holy Spirit and that he can take her as his wife.

But even before the angel speaks, even before we get to that part of the story, we have already heard the most important part, that Joseph is a good man.

So why did God choose Joseph to be the earthly father of his son? I believe it is because of this merciful, kind, grace filled spirit that he has in Joseph. We see a glimpse of the heart of God.

The Mercy of God

The Old Testament tells us over and over again that God is merciful and kind, slow to anger and abounding instead fast love. God, our heavenly Father does not wish to shame us, just as Joseph did not wish to shame Mary. God’s righteousness is not about humiliation or vengeance, but about mercy that protects life. And we see this in the very beginning of the Old Testament.

When God casts Adam and Eve out of the garden, he makes them a set of clothes. Before shutting the doors, he makes them a set of clothes. He’s not sending them out into the scary world without anything, but he makes them a set of clothes. When Cain kills Abel, God again shows mercy.

God confronts him and then Cain says, your punishment is to become a wanderer and a fugitive. And Cain responds in fear and despair. My punishment is greater than I can bear today. You have driven me away from the soil and I shall be hidden from your face. I shall be a fugitive and a wanderer on earth, and anyone who meets me may kill me.

Cain expects death. He expects vengeance. But God responds not with execution, but protection. He says: Not so. Whoever kills Cain will suffer a sevenfold vengeance. And the Lord put a mark on Cain so that no one who came upon him would kill him.

The first chapters of Genesis show us God’s kindness, God’s mercy and God’s grace.

And then we have Jonah.

Jonah is furious with God when God decides to spare the evil people of Nineveh, people whom Jonah believes deserve destruction. Jonah wanted to see Ni

neveh destroyed. He wanted to see hell fire and brimstone rain down upon the people.

But God chose to show mercy. And Jonah responds with this astonishing prayer:

O Lord, is this not what I said when I was still in my own country? This is why I fled to Tarshish at the beginning, for I knew that you are a gracious and merciful God. Slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love and relenting from punishment.

Jonah knows exactly who God is, and that makes him angry.

What Jonah throws back at God in frustration is what we confess in faith. That mercy is not a failure of justice, but the very heart of God.

Going back to Joseph. What if Joseph had brought Mary to the center of the village and condemned her to death?

The baby Jesus would not have been born if the earthly father of Jesus had not held dear those same virtues of mercy, kindness and compassion.

Remember Joseph and Remember Mercy

And so this week, as we gather to celebrate the birth of Christ, remember Joseph. Remember his mercy, his compassion and his kindness. Remember that in Joseph we see the grace of God, our heavenly Father, made known to us through Jesus Christ, our Lord. Amen.