To read devotions based on this sermon, click here.
Why was he born blind?
Grace to you and peace from God our Father and from the Lord Jesus Christ, his Son. Amen.
In seminary, the professor who taught Lutheran Confessions had a habit of answering our questions with a question of his own: “Why do you ask that question?”
And oftentimes we, as the students, would begin to stammer—a little panic, nervous.
But the professor wasn’t trying to shame us. He was trying to uncover the deeper question, the theological struggle that was rooted in our initial question.
Last week in the gospel, the disciples asked Jesus, “Lord, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” But that wasn’t really their question. The deeper question is, why do bad things happen?
Why was he born blind?
And Jesus never answers the question.
Why didn’t you stop this?
Today we have a similar situation. Jesus comes to Martha and Mary after their brother has died. And both sisters say, “Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.” Now it’s not really a question, but there is a question rooted in this accusation:
Where were you?
Why didn’t you stop this?
And these are the questions we ask ourselves at one time or another. If God is kind, merciful, and good, then why do bad things happen? Why didn’t God stop 9/11 or Pearl Harbor? Why doesn’t God stop war?
Why didn’t God protect my child, my parent, my friend, my loved one? Why doesn’t God stop cancer or car accidents? Why are some people healed while others die?
These are not small questions. And the reality is these questions are too big for us to answer.
The answer to our why
Sometimes the answer to these questions is free will. People choose violence over peace. They choose harm over love. They choose selfishness over selflessness.
And that explains some things, but not everything.
Because sometimes there is no clear reason. Sometimes it is no one’s fault. And that is incredibly hard to accept. We want an explanation. We want someone or something to blame.
And when we can’t find someone or something to blame, then we blame God.
And so when Jesus finally arrives in Bethany, we can understand the pain and even the anger of Martha and Mary. “Lord, if you had been here,” Martha says it first, and then Mary.
And when Mary says the words, he begins to weep.
Some versions of the Bible say, “Jesus wept,” and it becomes the shortest verse in the Bible. It is a very powerful verse. Jesus weeps with Mary. He weeps for Lazarus. He weeps for the brokenness of the world, just as Jesus weeps with us.
The truth is, we can question God all that we want. We can even accuse God.
But we need to remember that many of our questions will not be answered in this life.
Why? Because we only know in part
We all know First Corinthians 13: “Love is patient, love is kind. Love does not boast, is not envious or rude.” We tend to think of that in terms of romantic love. But the reality is Paul is writing this letter to churches in Corinth that are arguing with one another, each one saying, “I’m better than you.” “Well, we’re better than you because we speak in tongues.” “And we’re better than you because we do good deeds.”
And they’re just at each other’s throats.
Can you imagine the Christian church being divided like that?
Some things never change.
And so then Paul goes on and he says, in regard to what we know: “For we know only in part, and we prophesy only in part. But when the complete comes, the partial will come to an end. For now we only see a reflection, as in a mirror. But then we shall see face to face. Now I know only in part; then I will know fully, even as I have been fully known.”
That passage reminds us that we will not have the answers to all the questions in this life, because in this world we can only see a little bit. We cannot see the whole picture, and we do not understand the fullness of God’s ways.
Why Jesus cries
But here is what we do see: when Martha speaks, she tries to hold her faith in tension with her anger toward God. She says to Jesus, “I know that he will be raised at the resurrection on the last day.”
Mary—Mary doesn’t hold anything back. She brings her full grief, anger, and heartbreak and lays it at the feet of Jesus: “Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.”
And Jesus does not rebuke either woman. Jesus meets Martha in her words, and Jesus meets Mary in her tears.
And that is the good news.
Jesus doesn’t stand at a distance and try to explain suffering to us. Rather, Jesus enters into the grief, the pain, and the sorrow.
Jesus weeps with us in our pain.
Jesus does not abandon us, even when it feels like he has.
So when we ask, “Why, Lord? Why my brother? Why my sister? Why? Why my loved one? Why my parent? Why my friend?”
We may not receive an answer, but we are not left alone. Because the God we know in Jesus Christ is a God who weeps with us, a God who stays beside us, a God who loves us even in the midst of everything we do not understand. Amen.
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter via email